Winner – William Turner Challenge Cup Runner-up – James S Bell Cup
| Year | Winner | Club | Runner-up | Club | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | David Ball | Donaghadee | Matthew Stevenson | Castle | ||
| 2022 | Jackie Erskine | Bangor | Matthew Crawford | Bangor | ||
| 2021 | Aaran O'Keefe | Banbridge | Matthew Hastings | Bangor | ||
| 2020 | Cancelled | |||||
| 2019 | Cameron Gaw | Donaghadee | Colin Todd | Whitehead | ||
| 2018 | Gerard McGleave | Divis | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | ||
| 2017 | Noel Graham | Lisnagarvey | S McKinley | Whitehead | ||
| 2016 | S McKinley | Whitehead | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | ||
| 2015 | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | Mitchell Albert | Balmoral | ||
| 2014 | Neil Mulholland | Lisnagarvey | Nigel Beggs | Whitehead | ||
| 2013 | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | Aiden Corrigan | Portadown | ||
| 2012 | Gerard McGleave | Divis | Noel Graham | Lisnagarvey | ||
| 2011 | Michael Bickerstaff | Balmoral | Philip Cromie | Lisnagarvey | ||
| 2010 | Geaeme McKee | Bangor | Michael Bickerstaff | Balmoral | ||
| 2009 | Gerard McGleave | Divis | Ryan Craig | Balmoral | ||
| 2008 | Barry Browne | Whitehead | Robert Hastings | Bangor | ||
| 2007 | Neil Mulholland | Lisnagarvey | Annesley Harrison | Balmoral | ||
| 2006 | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | Derek Wright | Portadown | ||
| 2005 | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | Noel Graham | Lisnagarvey | ||
| 2004 | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | Jonathan Ross | Lisnagarvey | ||
| 2003 | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | Geffrey McMullan | Portadown | ||
| 2002 | Noel Graham | Lisnagarvey | J Phillips | Whitehead | ||
| 2001 | Martin McHugh | Whitehead | Noel Graham | Lisnagarvey | ||
| 2000 | Jonathan Ross | Lisnagarvey | Clifford Craig | Bangor | ||
| 1999 | James McKenny | Dromore | Mark Shannon | Bangor | ||
| 1998 | Clifford Craig | Bangor | W Keys | Whitehead | ||
| 1997 | G Moore | Banbridge | Brendan Power | Divis | ||
| 1996 | Michael Dunlop | Ormeau | Dessie Hill | Carrickfergus | ||
| 1995 | Noel Graham | Lisnagarvey | Michael Dunlop | Ormeau | ||
| 1994 | Gary Scott | Bangor | J McCullough | Lisnagarvey | ||
| 1993 | N Weir | Rathfriland | S Hall | Ormeau | ||
| 1992 | Alec Lightbody | Bangor | M Kelly | Musgrave | ||
| 1991 | Noel Graham | Lisnagarvey | Ernie Parkinson | Ormeau | ||
| 1990 | Rodney McCutcheon | Bangor | C Quinn | Banbridge | ||
| 1989 | Tommy Turkington | Balmoral | P Devlin | Divis | ||
| 1988 | A Tate | Rathfriland | N Booth | 22nd Old Boys | ||
| 1987 | A McMullan | Balmoral | I Gardner | Carrickfergus | ||
| 1986 | P McAllister | Carrickfergus | Tommy Turkington | Balmoral | ||
| 1985 | J Higgins | YRCD | T Stewart | Clarendon | ||
| 1984 | I Craig | Rathfriland | Michael Dunlop | Ormeau | ||
| 1983 | Maurice McKeown | Bangor | William Pierson | Portadown | ||
| 1982 | Dessie Hill | Whitehead | Stephen Moran | Carrickfergus | ||
| 1981 | Chris F Wallace | Carrickfergus | C Irons | Carrickfergus | ||
| 1980 | T Porter | Donaghadee | C Davis | Banbridge | ||
| 1979 | Chris F Wallace | Carrickfergus | C Campbell | Donaghadee | ||
| 1978 | R Foreman | Victoria | A Murphy | Carrickfergus | ||
| 1977 | Sammy Ashwood | Balmoral | Maurice McKeown | Bangor | ||
| 1976 | H Wallace | Carrickfergus | Maurice McKeown | Bangor | ||
| 1975 | C Worthington | North Down | M Allely | Donaghadee | ||
| 1974 | Sammy Ashwood | Balmoral | J Craig | Victoria | ||
| 1973 | W Rosbotham | Lisnagarvey | C Stewart | Musgrave | ||
| 1972 | J Buchanan | Woodvale | J Turtle | St Stephen’s | ||
| 1971 | J Higgins | YRCD | Sammy Ashwood | Balmoral | ||
| 1970 | D Laverty | Woodvale | E Gaw | Bangor | ||
| 1969 | J Higgins | YRCD | C Stewart | South Belfast | ||
| 1968 | G Barnes | 22nd Old Boys | R Pollock | Woodvale | ||
| 1967 | S Millar | Windsor | T Smyth | Lisnagarvey | ||
| 1966 | T Cull | Musgrave | S Allen | Connsbrook | ||
| 1965 | D Laverty | Woodvale | J P McHaffie | Woodvale | ||
| 1964 | J Buchanan | Woodvale | J Palmer | Portadown | ||
| 1963 | W S Tate | Bangor | R A Williamson | South Belfast | ||
| 1962 | R D Younger | Woodvale | D Lavery | Woodvale | ||
| 1961 | Trevor Kennedy | Lisnagarvey | A Lynn | RUC | ||
| 1960 | G Sloan | Ballynafeigh | S Doran | Botanic |